In my last post (and it is very funny, I admit, to go from writing about how this season sucks eggs to talking about having fun pushing keys), I talked about the ways in which Blizzard has left Season 2 of Midnight a bleeding, player-interest-killing mess, with overtuned raid fights, overwrought gearing that killed a lot of the conventional and fun gameplay routes to gear on alts in particular – but also, that I was still playing, still likely to push for seasonal goals (at least Ahead of the Curve on the raid and Keystone Myth even with Blizzard’s jerk-ass move of bumping the rating requirement by 200 points for only the “whale” achievement), and that I was generally finding my fun (perhaps not as clearly as this statement given that my post was much more of a semi-structured rant, but nevertheless!).

Well, with Forever launched and running its cycle (anecdotally, my friends list is already back to more Retail players at most times than Forever, which I will talk about more in a Forever post), I felt like it was a good time to push, and so starting that launch week, I made my final push for the season to secure the Keystone Myth achievement, going from 3444 rating at that time to 3610, ending (for now) with Resilient +17s and half the dungeons timed on +18, receiving my second Timelost Saddle of the expansion (which I used to purchase the Shadowlands Season 4 grape Kool Aid man) and marking my second season pushing primarily as a healer, this time on Restoration Shaman. So, how’d it go?

The Good
Resto Shaman Is Dumb Simple to Start but Fun to Master
Resto Shaman has generally been in a solid A/A- tier for healers this season – not yet truly a meta healer by losing out to Mistweaver Monks last season and Holy Paladins this season, but a solid choice beneath the top edge of the meta. I think, after 3 seasons playing Resto Shaman as a focused alt, I can now speak confidently to some of the reasons why that is.
At most low key levels, up to like +12s, Resto Shaman can be played with incredible ease by simply farting out your totems in response to damage while keeping Surging Totem (for Totemic at least) up. Group took a big spike of damage? Healing Stream Totem goes down, and with Lively Totems from Totemic, an immediate free Chain Heal too. Now the group is likely healthy enough and getting a trickle of steady healing from that totem plus the Healing Rain from Surging Totem. Big sustained incoming damage mechanic coming out? Healing Tide Totem and you can resume DPS. Huge damage spike with rapid followup? Spirit Link and then send a couple Chain Heals and you’re probably good. Panicked but need big group healing quickly? Rolling out Chain Heal spam until the group is stable often works well enough and with a typical talent loadout and mana pool boosters (proper spellthread plus the +mana meta gem) without being too mana inefficient. Earth Shield management is automatic since you basically always take the talent that makes it an hour buff with no charges on yourself and one additional target, and Riptide on your tank will often get you most of the way through as high as 12s unless the group is magnetically attracted to avoidable damage. Even then, most of these basic, binary choice paths will push the margins well enough that even an awful group can still be kept alive!
But the fun of Resto Shaman, I found, is in the optimized play you can get as you start to better understand your combo setups and how to properly manage downtime to maximize it. Keeping Riptide not just on cooldown but on as much of the group as possible means you have a potent HoT constantly rolling against incoming damage on multiple targets which also provides an amplifier to your targeted castable heals via Tidal Waves. Keeping Riptide on CD also gives more Stormstream Totem apex talent procs and Deeply Rooted Elements free Ascendence procs, which are very useful/marginally useful (you can save two Stormstream Totem charges and that extends the functional number of Healing Stream Totem charges you have which also means more Lively Totems free Chain Heals, while Ascendence randomly means sometimes it’ll proc during maintenance downtime when you aren’t blasting any other actual healing but it’ll also often proc in the heat of combat and give a decent boost of power to a lot of your healing when you need it!), not to mention that having Riptide constantly refreshing means Ancestral Vigor is up on more of the party more often, which means more health for partywide unavoidable damage and a bigger cushion to recover against. Primal Tide Core also makes it possible at a lot of times to have all 5 party members with Riptide on them, which makes recovering big damage spikes so much easier.

So early in the season, I was still brute-forcing a lot of healing scenarios with raw throughput from Chain Heal and targeted Healing Waves, coupled with more sparse use of Riptide, but as I started to push into the teen-key range, Riptide management became the core of the gameplay, and it made more time during combat to do damage and manage larger damage spikes instead of needing to respond immediately and in panic to incoming damage spikes. With Riptide maintained out of combat most of the time, I could spend combat simply using totems to cover most gaps, refreshing and using Riptide charges as they came up, and keeping Surging Totem down, then getting time to use damage spells to compliment the very strong Resto Shaman damage profile that comes with simply keeping Healing Rain down thanks to Acid Rain and the incredible synergy with Totemic’s main Surging Totem and the current Season 2 tier bonus, which spawns a high number of extra and free Healing Rains that also deal damage via Acid Rain.
By the end of my push, my average healing parse was like a 2-3 (because I was in generally good PUG groups that rarely required healing outside of maintenance of Riptide and unavoidable spikes) while my damage parses were consistently 85th percentile-plus, and that inversion of expectations was fun, because those low healing parses weren’t causing death or chaos – everyone was alive and thriving, so hey, let’s do big damage instead!
Lastly for this season’s dungeon pool, Resto Shaman has a generally good dispel profile – 7 out of 8 dungeons have bad poison debuffs that often tend to pool and collect at a moment where Poison Cleansing Totem is a huge win, Curse dispel is marginally useful in a couple of cases like Murder Row before the 3rd boss and failure states leading to boss 1 in Den of Nalorakk, and Purge as an offensive dispel is highly useful in Ruby Life Pools on the route to the last boss but even more useful in Temple of Sethraliss, as removing Accumulated Charges from the lightning adds on the way to the third boss there prevents a ton of groupwide damage that would otherwise be unavoidable.
While Resto Shaman is not the meta healer du jour and has some gaps where it can kinda do well but could be better served (the poison dispel from PCT is great but some poisons like the stacking health reduction in Murder Row demand a far better and more available dispel option), it has a great toolkit that is generally well-match to the seasonal dungeon rotation while also having a strong and largely passive damage profile that allows it to do strong damage while still basically just casting heals, which is great for Mythic Plus as high key pushing is largely about maximizing damage output across the party while meeting necessary healing and mitigation checks.
Dungeon Tuning Is Mostly Good (Now)

After the mid-season patch in 12.1.5 and some tuning passes, there are not too many outliers in the dungeon pool for extreme difficulty. Altar of Fangs has some tough pulls, Blinding Vale has a couple of unforgiving trash pulls regardless of route selection, and Murder Row’s last boss is a big movement skill check for tanks while also being spongy because DPS priority always falls to adds, there isn’t really a dungeon I can think of as excessively unfair at this point. Some early season issues like add health scaling on the second boss of Ruby Life Pools have been fixed, and I think the only outlier boss I can even think of is due to a strange issue because of the fight design – Avatar of Sethraliss, whose tuning is very beneficial for reactive and throughput healers and less so for proactive or ramp healers, especially poor Discipline Priests who are fighting uphill to get health into that boss given that Atonement generally requires a meaty target you can blast with damage for a prolonged period while the healing phase on the fight involves lots of small, easily killed adds that don’t allow Atonement to ramp well.
Scaling Is Good And The Loot Differential for Raiding Isn’t Going To Affect The Vast Majority of Players
Midnight’s key scaling remains in a good place in my opinion, where lower level keys are accessible, fun, and friendly, which makes the solution to find adequate challenge simple – keep pushing until you find your limits. +10s for maximum vault rewards remains an easy mark to hit for the majority of the Mythic Plus audience, while +12s for maximum crest rewards and a more enjoyable experience (sans affixes with gameplay requirements) is also quite easily attainable for most players, in my opinion. There is definitely still some fear and psychological damage for M+ pushers that the changes to raid loot, particularly the endboss Myth 9/6 loot and cantrips, and how those would negatively impact pure M+ players, but the difference amounts to between 3-5% DPS overall and isn’t the difference between timing or not timing a key, although the first time you have a close-call run where you miss a timer by sub-15 seconds you’re still gonna naturally think of how that gap could be closed with said loot. But unless you’re literally pushing for rank 1 (maybe top 0.1% too, but it still probably isn’t necessary there), the uber loot from the current raid tier isn’t going to force you to do a lot of raiding and I haven’t seen anyone excluded or included based on the presence or absence of cantrip items. Doesn’t stop it from feeling bad, but how it feels and what it actually means are different and important to distinguish, in my opinion.
The Mixed
Healing Tuning and Triage
Midnight Season 2 marks yet another moment where Blizzard pushed a healing-targeted tuning pass during PTR where the health of players and the incoming damage they’d receive from enemy mobs was increased by the same percentage, with corresponding buffs to defensive self-heals but not to healer spells. The goal, same as ever, was to balance healing so that it was less of a ping-pong game and had a stronger triage element, where players would descend through health pools at a slower pace which would allow more decision-making and reaction time for healers to respond before a player was in meaningful danger. And, to give Blizzard some credit here, they did stick the landing at most lower levels of content. In keys beneath 12s and raid up through Heroic, you do have time to be more strategic and responsive or even reactive, and less preplanning is generally less punished than it was even last season, where partywide damage spikes in Mythic Plus often pushed health bars into the dirt and forced you to really strongly preplan a lot of cooldowns and keep maintenance up out of combat or else you’d risk losing a party member.
However, on harder Heroic bosses near the end of the raid tier and higher keys, this triage gameplay largely gives way under the weight of difficulty scaling. While it is still better in my opinion than last season was as difficulty rises, you do definitely still end up in a situation where unplanned damage intake or mistimed cooldowns can feel extremely punishing – and, to be fair, that is probably okay at the high end of play, but I still find myself wishing that at least in situations where players take unplanned damage that I could do more to save them. The ping-pong still happens, which also reduces triage-oriented power boosts like Resto Shaman Mastery! It still feels like the penalty for group failures of mechanics is largely laid at the feet of the healer, who then has to struggle to bring back up a player who stood in bad and that feels bad because…
Blizzard Promised Penalties that Would Involve DPS More, But Mostly Failed to Deliver
The season 2 outline blog post Blizzard put back up when everyone was shitting on the dungeon pool for the season made clear that Blizzard was cooking a situation with penalties for mechanical failure carrying an impact to DPS players and not always being healer emergencies, which sounded great. One of the things many people ask for from Final Fantasy XIV in WoW is the idea of damage downs, where a DPS player making mechanical mistakes is punished by doing less damage, which is far more impactful to them and likely to be corrected than them simply taking a boatload of extra damage, which most bad DPS players will just blame on the healer. I was so excited to hear that because I think that correctives like that in gameplay make better players and sharpen skills so that a DPS player doesn’t simply cheese a defensive and put the burden onto their healer or just, like many players I know, genuinely ignore or fail to notice their own mechanical shortcomings and then type “WHAT HAPPENED” in party chat when they get blown the fuck apart by a swirly or say “bullshit” in voice when they didn’t dodge the easy and obvious huge circle under their feet.
However, Blizzard kinda…didn’t stick the landing on this idea, because throughout the seasonal pool, I can only think of two obvious cases where DPS misplays result in damage penalties or fight elongation, and both still can get blamed on a healer anyways. Both, funny enough, are in Temple of Sethraliss, where the third boss has the triple-spire soak lines, and failing to soak all 3 results in a damage penalty (and also a modest partywide damage burst for the healer anyways!) and the last boss has the soak orbs where DPS have to soak them and there are always 3, because soaking them reduces healing you do which means you can’t soak as a healer (because obviously that’s bad especially on the boss you have to heal back to full health!) and you can’t soak as a tank (because every tank relies on some form of self-healing for their sustained survivability and the debuff lasts long enough that a tank who soaks orbs too much will die due to lack of self-sustain eventually), and even that mechanic is kind of a stretch because it relies on the DPS knowing that them not soaking but the orbs still being soaked by someone whose healing throughput matters means the fight drags on far too long which is…not something I would count on, even being charitable. Most people know not soaking will kill the party, but there’s far less clarity around what soaking as a tank or healer does and how that would meaningfully affect a DPS player in any real substantial way.
It is a start, to be fair, but I would like to see this ramped up substantially more in future seasons because I think it is the missing piece that leads to healers being less played (while not to the same extent of the tank shortage, healer shortage is a thing at times!), and I think that DPS players often don’t have a lot of clarity of mechanics, not just for stereotypical “har har DPS mains are stupid morons” reasons but because genuinely the game makes most failures a healer problem and at times the ways in which a DPS player can fail and cause problems aren’t super clear. If the penalty for failure was no damage taken but instead a huge damage done reduction for even like 8-12 seconds, then healers would be more popular to play and I think DPS players would more quickly learn how to handle more mechanics accurately. I would rather fail a huge bloodlust triple pull in a dungeon for a lack of DPS due to faulty mechanics on the DPS instead of being healer and tank endurance checks most of the time (which can also fall on the DPS being too low, but that’s also not often clear to a lot of DPS players because most of how you validate what is enough DPS is external tools and websites and not in-game).
The Loot Table This Season Is Genuinely, Mostly Awful for Dungeons Which Exacerbates the Strength of Raid Loot
Long section title, oof. But let’s discuss!
Most of the dungeon loot this season has Versatility on it. Versatility is a boring, do little stat that most specs hate and is generally a sign of a badly tuned spec if you favor it, because it’s like a less effective version of your base stat and armor/elemental resistance rolled into a single rating-based stat. Blizzard, I think, is beginning to understand that players generally do not like Versatility, that it is generally boring and dull, and that people would prefer not to have to dance around it because the raid this season has almost 0 Versatility, but then the dungeon pool is full to the brim with Vers items.
What this means is that while Mythic Plus remains the fastest overall way for the average player to gear up a character, and item level still mostly trumps secondary stat allocations, it feels pretty bad to have basically no chase items you actually want in Mythic Plus, no real viable bonus roll targets from the whole mode of play, and for that gap to be as pronounced as it is, particularly with trinkets, which is where the delta between Mythic Plus power and raid power is at the largest. Blizzard has generally been okay about doing loot table passes for Mythic Plus in the past, making a point of making tweaks and additions or subtractions as needed to fit a given season’s power curve and goals (Season 3 of The War Within removed every cape from dungeons because of the Reshii Wraps and added some items like the necklace to Operation Floodgate), so it just feels bad that Blizzard seems on the one hand to have gotten the memo given the raid loot table but on the other hand decided to not touch up the loot table for dungeons and leave them with all that Versatility. And sure, some specs like it, hell, even my Resto Shaman main still likes it more than Mastery, but not enough to be excited for or bonus rolling dungeons for Vers-pieces!
My wishlist is that we get better stat balance between modes of play next season but also that they take a particular pass at trinket tuning, because the sad fact is that a lot of trinkets in Mythic Plus kinda suck this expansion and burst trinkets with use effects in particular are so bad this season that many of them give less stats over the same duration as lower item level trinkets from last season! Part of the pressure to push raid for bonus rolls is that the trinkets in the raids this tier are far superior to just about anything you can get from Mythic Plus, on top of the myriad other reasons bonus rolling is almost always limited to raids this season.
The Bad
No-Target, No-Cast Bleeds, Poisons, and Face Slaps
I remarked upon this in my Season 2 rant post, but it bears repeating here – the worst aspect of healing this season is the number of different big hits and DoTs that carry no target or cast bar warning and just blast a random player for a truckload of damage, which feels antithetical to the whole healer triage adjustments they made to start the season and the addon purge! Multiple dungeons have trash that, without a target warning or cast bar, put a nasty ticking bleed up that does a ton of damage far beyond what a normal random target rot damage ability would do and they feel awful to counterplay as a healer and also for the target. Temple of Sethraliss, King’s Rest, and Den of Nalorakk all have these nasty things, and as with a lot of healing this season, on low keys they’re fine but they become real bad gut punches on higher keys, especially because of UI settings where you might not even see a bleed on a target if you can’t dispel it, so it can start to be a guessing game of who is getting trucked and why. As usual, being Dwarf can have some payoff at the key levels where this matters most, but if you’re pushing to Myth, you’re not likely going to see that many Dwarves so as a healer you just have to either set your debuff filter to not exclude things you can’t dispel or just learn where the bleeds are and push harder against players who start rapidly rotting out. In some dungeons, this is even worse, because they’re instant damage instead of DoTs, or things that reduce max health, both of which happen in Murder Row, as rogue-styled trash mobs can backstab random targets and a DPS or healer player getting double-tapped by these is often in severe danger when that happens, and the poison these same mobs apply reduces max health per stack, so multiple attacks without a poison dispel can mean a tank that simply cannot live. And this would be fine if every group comp had a way to remove the poison, but that’s the issue – you need a Druid, Paladin, Monk, or Evoker to reliably remove it, and while Shaman can use Poison Cleansing Totem every 2 minutes and could potentially pull it off at a high-ish stack count, that’s not enough here. So if you play the current meta comp for DPS and then like, say….a Prot Warrior tank and Holy Priest healer, then you’re boned when that poison stacks up high enough! That feels pretty awful!
My take is this – random target stuff like this is fine if I get warning, even just a short cast bar and a chance to respond ahead of time with external support for the targeted player, or if the tough and inconsistently dispellable thing is short enough duration that lacking the dispel isn’t going to seriously put a group in jeopardy if otherwise played well, but I think Blizzard quite seriously missed the mark in many cases this season on this notion, and that feels bad. I never like to be in a run where a death feels inevitable and unavoidable even with pixel-perfect gameplay, and I am surely not alone in that. My guess is that Blizzard is using these mechanics to force groups to pull smaller – that the answer to multi-hit backstabs in Murder Row or 8 stacks of poison is “pull less, dummy” but the timer tuning is built around aggressive chain pulling and smart play. Murder Row’s first area is so tightly tuned that you basically need to do it in 3 pulls total from entrance to first boss or otherwise the timer pressure becomes too great, and that challenge is fun! – but less so when a dice roll of random targets can dumpster your run. And granted, you still have to make mistakes for that to truly end a run, but the degree of play needed on even mid-tier key levels to do the entry in 3 setup there can be pretty high in a way that feels out of line, and it seems largely that way because Blizzard probably doesn’t want us pulling it in 3 pulls, but then it’s a question of how the timer ought to be tuned to allow some more leniency there. I think Blizzard has better levers to use to limit mega pulls and crazy shit happening, and I think they ought to look more at timer pressure points and reducing roleplay pauses instead of trying to make it so that pulling more than one pack at a time accumulates stuff that cannot be controlled. Big pulls make Mythic Plus exciting and fun, and they should be very highly challenging but also reasonably so and solvable by all groups with smart play instead of having a pileup of anti-fun bullshit that makes them feel worse.
Roleplay and Spawning Timers Eating Up The Clock
This season has a ton of moments where roleplay events and timewasters eat into the timer for the dungeon run, which feels bad because there’s often no real counterplay to these. Murder Row has it on literally every boss except the third, and on top of that also has a big pause with the demonic gate that you use to access the route to the third boss, so literally every segment of the dungeon forces you to wait for some scripted event to happen. Ruby Life Pools has it on the third boss – a minor offense but it does eat up like 10-15 seconds of just waiting there. Temple of Sethraliss has RP and spawn animations for the second and third bosses, King’s Rest has the same for the 1st boss, second boss trash approach, and the last boss, Altar of Fangs has it for the second and third bosses, Blinding Vale doesn’t have it (hooray!), Den of Nalorakk has RP at the entrance and then on every boss plus again after the second boss to move back out of the dream world, and Voidscar Arena has some to spawn multiple waves of trash before the first boss and then a tiny bit to spawn the first boss. It’s all little stuff, but there is just so much of it this season and at multiple points of most of the dungeons in a way that makes it feel so much worse and dragging than even single larger events like the pre-Skovald RP in Halls of Valor! Sure, these are all supposed to be factored into the timer, but I’d rather have the same timers without needing to wait on over a minute of total RP per dungeon or other silly timewasters like someone prematurely releasing after a death on the second boss in Den of Nalorakk having to run through the entire ice section just to get back to the fire to meditate and leave it to join the party (which is an outlier and bad play in high keys, but hey).
The Myth Tier Point Requirement Boost
Keystone Myth was added last season for reaching 3,400 Mythic rating. A good challenge to be sure, but one that still took a lengthy grind for most players to push towards doing 16s. This season, because of “difficulty,” Blizzard upped Myth to 3,600. I ranted about this already in the last post so I’ll keep it short here, but this logic fails when every other level of achievement was left untouched and are unquestionably easier this season. If you truly thought the difficulty of this season warranted such a huge shift for Myth (requiring nearly +2 additional key levels per dungeon because of how slowly rating accrues beyond +12s without new affixes), then surely the lower tier achievements would have also required some level of adjustment too. But they don’t, because of course, the difficulty feels roughly the same at high key levels (subjective, but hey) as Season 1 but the whales you can count on to stay engaged and push towards goals had to push harder because you could count on them reliably wanting to rise to the challenge if they complained about it and saw through the flimsy excuse. And hey, I’m here proving the point, I’m salty with Blizzard for pushing this bullshit and withholding the news until the season started to lag behind metrics but I’m also writing this having done exactly what they wanted me to do – padding out the numbers by pushing beyond my prior limits to a new level of attainment. But I still think 3,400 was perfectly difficult enough and I know a few players who would have likely tried for it this season more at that level but who have mostly or at least seem to have ruled it out at 3,600 because of the increase coupled with some other issues.
Forever’s Impact, Good and Bad
I am going to piss off the Classic Andys a bit here in a moment, because I am of two minds about launching Forever at the point they did in an already-troubled retail season that has been bleeding players and interest. On the one hand, finding groups was a lot harder than it already was prior to Forever launch during that launch week, because the new shiny WoW thing was a whole other version that was disconnected from Keystones and pushing – and that’s fine and expected to a point. I don’t think Blizzard purposefully tanked this retail season to make Forever seem better or anything, I just think they stumbled blindly through their hubris into a bad retail season that has pushed a lot of issues to the forefront and created problems. However, after the initial Forever rush died down, I had an easier time pushing keys in retail – because, in my opinion, the general Classic Andy (the type that makes shitting on retail their whole personality even while still playing it) is pretty awful at the game, and filtering them out into Forever made finding higher competency and skill groups more possible and even likely. Sure, I had a fair few slash-abandons, but it was less than last season and, in my estimation since I don’t track it, fewer total runs to reach Myth even with the higher rating requirement. As I mentioned up top, I think my anecdotal experience is that there have been waves of interest and disinterest in Forever, and that ebb and flow will likely continue through the first raid release next month in Forever, at which point I think some things will become clearer and people will decide on their homes – and I think the pattern will look a lot closer to the prior Classic launches than people might expect, with sharp and massive initial interest that quickly fades into a much-smaller core audience. It will still be popular and well-loved – but I think people looking at “15 million characters created” and planning for how Blizzard is gonna kill Retail and divert everything to Forever are misleading themselves into delusion. Again, more fodder for when I discuss my own engagement with Forever, but the impact the launch had is important to state here, because there were some nights where I refreshed LFG for up to 90 minutes, didn’t find a single group that passed my smell test, and logged out without doing anything from Retail. And, to be fair, that also happened prior to Forever launch as well – but that launch week was touch and go until the hype rocket started to come back to earth a bit more.
Spec Balance Is Great, Mostly…But Bugs, Long-Lived Outliers and Delayed/Mid-Season Tuning Kills Hype
On a spec balance front, this is actually a relatively well-balanced season of Mythic Plus overall. There are high and low performers but generally every spec has something they can latch onto and I’ve seen a remarkably large array of group comps even compared to last season, where things quickly settled into a couple of OP DPS specs and a generally preferred tank and healer spec. There is definitely an emergent meta comp (Blood DK/Holy Paladin/Elemental Shaman/Subtlety Rogue/Arms Warrior) but even that gets shaken up with Arcane Mage and that level of meta specificity is really reserved for the absolute bleeding edge of key pushing, more so than usual – and that is stellar.
However, Blizzard has fucked up hugely this season multiple times on the tuning front by clearly missing the point with a lot of tuning passes.
Both Unholy Death Knights and Subtlety Rogues had bugs that were impacting their DPS. In both cases, Blizzard rolled out two-fold fixes, where they buffed the specs by the percentage the bug was costing them while also fixing the bugs, effectively double-buffing them and creating substantially more powerful versions of both specs, which were then allowed to remain insanely OP for multiple weeks until Blizzard rolled back the buff tuning. In a less-balanced season, these would have been huge issues, but they haven’t actually been too bad because while it was insane that Blizzard handled these issues in that manner, it also hasn’t resulted in keys being done that would have otherwise been impossible – in fact, the top keys at this point are basically all post-fixes, and there’s still an interestingly-diverse meta. But this issue should not be happening in the first place and it reflects a lack of attentiveness from Blizzard that they knew about the bugs (all of which were reported on PTR), took months to address them in any way by issuing tuning, and then double-addressed them resulting in an incorrect megabuff.
Further, I am gonna piggyback onto another Zorthas video and agree that I think Blizzard’s tuning and class changes in mid-season patches are going a little bit too far in Midnight. Marksmanship Hunter has had major rotational changes in both 12.x.5 patches so far due to weird talent changes and tweaks, and a lot of Blizzard’s tuning in these patches has been a little bit too aggressive given how gearing is this season in particular but also generally, because these tuning changes shift away from balance and often change the meta, which means time and effort spent gearing a character, especially with bonus rolls and other systems interactions, goes to waste and feels pretty bad. While I don’t necessarily want to encourage the game to lean even harder into seasonality, I think that short of bug fixes or major gameplay feel issues, the spec you play in an x.0 patch should feel roughly the same as the spec in the x.5 and x.7 patches with major reworks and huge tweaks being held for seasonal rollout patches instead.
Looking Ahead – 5% By Spec In Season 3, 1% This Season?

So with the general categorical sorting done, overall, I still enjoyed pushing keys this season. Even with the stumbling and fumbling on Blizzard’s part through design here, I enjoyed my key push overall enough to still feel good about what the future looks like. I think that is in large part to what pushing keys is for me – a happy moment where my own play is the only thing I can really directly control for, no need to babysit and handhold through the basics and a higher ability to trust the players I am with to do their own homework and be prepared – in large part because my own group filtering logic has gotten relatively good at pushing me towards successful groups I can run with. Keys are the one avenue in which I feel like I have the most ability to show my skill expression and growth as a player, and where the effort I put in has a direct and earned payoff, and that always feels good. Even when the game is in a down time, keys feel great to me because once I get around the rough edges and design warts, there’s still something there that provides a fun puzzle to solve, and that puzzle and the solution to it evolve over the course of the season, which is really neat!

So I revisit a topic I thought more about last season – do I end up pushing for 1% title and mount this time? And the answer is…I’m less sure but also feeling more like I might actually do it this time. Last season, I set out with it as a goal, but I hit Myth the first time, nearly pushed a Mistweaver to a second Myth, and then kind of ran out of steam and stopped. This season, I expressly set out not expecting to do 1%, but also now, according to Raider.IO’s projections, I could potentially hit 1% by end of season with just another 200ish points of rating – which is a lot, but also isn’t that far off. I’m already in the top 3.5% of all players in M+ just by being at the Myth achievement level as is, which is much closer than last season’s Myth breakpoint put you! Plus we still have more power from the expansion of the Omnium Folio coming in December, after which the season will still likely run another 8-10 weeks, which gives plenty of time to slowly chip away – Resilient 18s, then 19s, maybe into 20s? I haven’t really committed yet for sure, because there is a certain satisfaction I feel from being done for the season – short of getting my guildies AOTC, I have killed every raid boss I want to, reached Myth, geared my Shaman to almost-max (I have one Hero track trinket that could use a boost up but otherwise good), and I have other things in my life I am working on and towards (my health and fitness plus I am attending my first GDC in March so I need to put some love into my portfolio and projects professionally!) – so I guess I am at a crossroads where it feels very attainable and yet also not necessarily as desirable as last season – especially since the Mythic mount this tier that would likely be reskinned for it isn’t nearly as cool.
However, Raider.IO has already set me on a path with additions they’ve made this season to prepare for changes to come next season, as Blizzard is looking to implement a top 5% per spec achievement that might (somewhat unclear at this point) take the place of the top 1% overall achievement. As it stands this season, right now, I am in the top 3.25% of Resto Shamans in the NA region, the top 4.86% of the spec globally, and in the top 2.53%/4.81% of healers in NA and globally, respectively, as well as being in the NA top 3.14% of all players and top 6% globally, which feels really incredible as an accomplishment for me. It seems like if I push forward towards Myth as it currently stands and a similar level of attainment next season on any spec I play, reaching that top 5% achievement would be very doable and rewarding, which is great.
As usual with Mythic Plus, I come back to the same place I end up most of the time with the mode – it is my happy place, where I feel the most at home, skill-expressed and sufficiently challenged while also rewarded for that investment in a commensurate and reasonable way, and so even with all the complaints I have and will lodge against the mode, the community, this season in particular, and Blizzard – it still manages to rope me in and provide me with an experience I find fulfilling overall. As long as Blizzard continues to put the focus and effort into it they have during Midnight thus far (with maybe less engagement bait for players like me, please), then I’ll continue to be happy with the mode and what it offers me.